Winter tyre test 205/55 R16 from the publisher Авторевю 2008 p.

You can read the full text of the test at the following link: https://autoreview.ru/articles/test
Place Model Description / Recommendations Cost
1
Nokian Hakkapeliitta 5
Traction on ice and snow
Handling on ice and snow
High resistance to slushplaning
Low traction on asphalt (in the class of studded tires)
Average handling on asphalt
Tires are the safest on a slippery road, but not the best choice for big cities, where most of the winter has to be driven on asphalt.
2
Michelin X-Ice North
Grip on ice and snow
High level of self-cleaning
Low rolling resistance (in the tyre category)
Noise
Tires demonstrate the best balance between purely winter and asphalt qualities, making them more attractive for urban use.
3
Vredestein Arctrac
Traction on ice and snow
Traction on asphalt
Handling on asphalt
Noise
Increased rolling resistance
Tires are the best option for studded tires for urban winter use. They will not fail on ice, and on asphalt they will allow you to drive fast and safely.
4
Continental ContiWinterViking 2
Ice Grip, Ice Handling, Snow Handling
Insufficient stability when driving on a winter road
Insufficient resistance to slushplaning
Studded tires that can be used both in the city and beyond its limits.
5
Goodyear UltraGrip Extreme
Traction properties on ice
Medium traction on snow
Good winter tires.
6
Pirelli Winter Carving Edge
Traction and control on ice
Traction on snow
Traction properties and handling on asphalt
Noise
Tires are more suitable for the northern regions of Russia than for large cities in its European part.
7
Gislaved Nord Frost 5
Grip properties on ice
Acoustic comfort
Insufficient resistance to slashing
Low stability when driving on winter roads
If the snow is thawing, mixed with water, the tires will "float" early. On the ruts, the car behaves unstable - it holds the straight line poorly and wanders. The quietest among studded tires.
8
Continental ContiVikingContact 5
Traction properties on snow
Traction and handling on ice in the non-treaded tyre class
Braking properties and handling on wet asphalt
For snow and ice - a great option, but for fast driving on asphalt, especially on wet, the tires are not suitable.
from 6 290 
9
Michelin X-Ice 2
Balanced performance on different surfaces
Traction and handling on snow
Traction on ice in non-studded tire category
Handling on ice
On asphalt - both in terms of coupling properties and handling, they are preferable to most non-studded competitors. This makes the tires particularly attractive for urban winter use.
10
Nokian Hakkapeliitta R
Traction properties on ice and snow in the non-studded tire class
Handling on ice and snow in the non-studded tire class
Traction on asphalt
Handling on asphalt
Tires are perfect for slippery roads, but on asphalt their capabilities are limited.
11
Gislaved Soft Frost 3
Traction on snow
Handling on ice in the non-studded tire class
Braking on wet asphalt in the non-studded tire class
Handling on asphalt
On dry asphalt, the tires demonstrate moderate traction properties, but on a wet surface, they significantly surpass their "soft" classmates in braking. For example, the more "prestigious" Continental ContiVikingContact 5 tires lose to Gislaved in braking distance by as much as 6.5 meters! But in other asphalt disciplines, there is either no difference between these tires or it is small and in favor of Continental tires.
from 4 280 
12
Barum Norpolaris
Grip properties on wet asphalt
Traction properties on ice and snow
Handling on ice and snow
Low resistance to slushplaning
On dry asphalt, the tires are helpless - if they somehow manage to steer around an obstacle while braking, the handling track experts noted too sluggish reactions to steering wheel turns and sharp skidding. On wet asphalt, the tires are redeemed - the car brakes well and confidently steers around the obstacle.
13
Continental ContiWinterContact TS 810
Winter driving stability
Traction and handling on asphalt
Traction properties and handling on ice
Low resistance to slushplaning
High rolling resistance
Tires are quite suitable for large cities in Russia, and they can be boldly installed on powerful cars, the owners of which do not intend to abandon active driving even in winter.
from 5 780 
14
Vredestein Nord-Trac
Mid-grip performance and snow handling
Traction properties on ice
Low stability of movement on a winter road
Traction properties on asphalt
The car brakes poorly, uncertainly bypasses an obstacle, and on the handling track it sharply skids. On ice, the tires work poorly, on asphalt too.
15
Yokohama Ice Guard IG20
Ice grip performance on a non-tread tire
Low rolling resistance
Ice and snow handling
Asphalt handling
Thanks to the soft porous tread rubber, Japanese tires show decent longitudinal traction properties on ice, but lag behind competitors on handling tracks: the car sharply, without warning, skids, which is difficult to control even for an experienced expert.
16
Federal Himalaya WS1
Tread properties on asphalt in the non-treaded tire class.
Traction on ice and snow
Handling on all types of surfaces
The handling of the car can be described in one word - slippery, both on snow and on ice. On asphalt, the tires look better - they are especially good at obstacle avoidance with braking.
17
Kingstar W411
Dry traction Wet traction Braking traction Cornering traction
Extremely low traction on ice and snow
Handling on ice, snow and wet asphalt
Low stability of movement on a winter road
Low resistance to slushplaning
The car skids very early and is extremely difficult to control. On snow-water porridge, these tires float sooner than others, and the stability on a road with ruts is the lowest. Wherever you throw it, there's a wedge everywhere. It's only on asphalt that the Chinese tires rise from the bottom lines to the middle ones. Although there's still a problem with handling here.