Winter tire test 205/55 R16 from the publisher За рулём 2012 p.

Place Model Description / Recommendations Cost
1
Nokian Hakkapeliitta 7
Excellent longitudinal traction on ice and acceleration on snow
Good braking and lateral traction on snow
Excellent traction
Minor remarks regarding handling on asphalt and comfort
Points: 929

Minor remarks regarding the directional stability on asphalt and comfort.
2
Continental ContiIceContact
Best snow traction and wet road braking
Good grip on ice, acceleration, and cross-slip on snow
Steering stability on any road
Minor remarks regarding handling, passability and comfort level
Points: 925

Suitable for any winter road.
from 10 450 
3
Michelin X-Ice North 2
Good traction on cross-axles on ice and longitudinal on snow, braking on dry asphalt, excellent roadability, good handling, directional stability
Minor remarks about the noise level
Points: 923

Suitable for any winter roads and winter off-road.
3
Goodyear UltraGrip Ice Arctic
Super snow traction and excellent acceleration on snow
Good longitudinal grip on ice
Wet grip braking on wet asphalt
Excellent traction
Complex directional stability on asphalt
Minor complaints about handling
Course stability on snowy roads and comfort
Points: 923

Will show their best qualities on snowy roads, indispensable on winter off-road.
from 9 040 
4
Pirelli Winter Carving Edge
Exceptional cross-ice traction
Good snow traction and dry asphalt braking
Excellent cornering stability on snowed-in roads
Low level of comfort
Points: 918

Suitable for any winter roads and off-road. Will give pleasure from driving the car.
5
Nordman 4
Optimal cross-snow traction
Good longitudinal grip on snow and ice, and braking on wet asphalt
High level of off-road traction
Increased noise level
Minor complaints regarding directional stability and ride smoothness
Points: 909

Suitable for any winter roads and off-road.
6
Gislaved Nord Frost 5
Best braking on dry and wet asphalt, Good braking and lateral grip on ice, Good cornering stability and ride comfort.
Increased fuel consumption
Low level of cross-country ability
Points: 905

They won't cope with any winter roads, but will show their best quality on asphalt.
7
Hankook W419 i Pike RS
Good braking and lateral grip on ice, longitudinal traction on snow
Economical at 90 km/h
Poor braking on dry and wet roads
Score: 886

Suitable for any winter road.
8
Bridgestone Ice Cruiser 7000
Mid-grip performance on ice
Good steering stability on any road
Tread pattern and smooth ride
The weakest lateral grip and acceleration on snow
Increased noise level
Scores: 855

Suitable for icy and slightly snowy roads.
9
Yokohama Ice Guard IG35+
Mid-grip properties on ice, Satisfactory handling performance and noise level.
The weakest acceleration on snow
Poor cross-country grip and braking on snow
Difficult handling
Low level of passability and smoothness of the ride
Points: 841

Suitable for icy and lightly snow-covered roads.
from 5 380 
10
Cordiant Polar 2
Good lateral grip on snow and braking on dry and wet asphalt, Satisfactory cornering stability and traction
The weakest coupling properties on ice and braking on snow
Slow acceleration on snow
Difficult handling
Low comfort level
Points: 808

Suitable for well-cleared and lightly snow-covered roads.
from 4 060 
11
Кама Евро 519
Acceptable traction
Average fuel consumption
The weakest braking on dry asphalt
Weak coupling properties on ice and snow, braking on wet asphalt
Difficult steering stability and handling
Points: 806

Only suitable for leisurely driving.
from 4 440