Winter tire test 205/55 R16 from the publisher За рулём 2015 p.

We tested the traction properties of snow tyres for the Golf-class cars on snow and asphalt. We assembled 13 sets of the most popular “rims” on the Russian market in the most common size for foreign cars, priced from 3300 to 8500 rubles per tyre.

We tested the tyres at the AVTOTEXNOPROM testing ground. The “white” tests (on snow and ice) were conducted in January-February at a temperature of -25
Place Model Description / Recommendations Cost
1
Nokian Hakkapeliitta 8
Excellent braking properties and lateral grip on ice, high snow traction
economical at any speed
outstanding directional stability on a snowy road, excellent mobility, precise handling on a winter road and course adherence on asphalt.
excellent braking properties on wet asphalt
minor comments regarding ride smoothness
noisy
Will be liked on any winter roads and off-road; will help save fuel.

Points: 932
from 3 600 
2
Continental ContiIceContact 2
Outstanding braking performance on asphalt, exceptional grip on snow and ice
high level of handling and traction
Minor complaints about directional stability on asphalt and comfort level
Most balanced tires for any winter road and off-road.

Score: 927
from 6 270 
3
Goodyear UltraGrip Ice Arctic
Outstanding braking performance on snow
excellent traction on snow, ice and asphalt
exceptional treadmiles
Difficulties with handling on winter roads and directional stability on snowy
low level of comfort
Will allow you to feel confident on any winter road, and off-road become a king.

Points: 916
from 9 040 
4
Pirelli Winter Ice Zero
Excellent braking properties and side traction on snow, high grip on ice
very good braking properties on asphalt
high off-road capability.
low level of comfort
minor complaints regarding handling and directional stability
Will give confidence on any winter roads.

Points: 914
from 6 300 
5
Michelin X-Ice North 3
Excellent braking properties on the asphalt
clear handling on winter roads and directional stability on the asphalt.
modest traction properties on ice
For any winter road; will be pleased with long trips.

Points: 885
from 51 670 
6
Nordman 5
Average traction on snow and ice
Economical at any speed
Good for traction
Smooth handling and comfort level ratings
Weak braking performance on dry asphalt
Capable of handling any winter roads and off-road; help save fuel.

Points: 884
from 4 610 
7
Gislaved Nord Frost 100
Good braking performance on asphalt
smooth assessments in terms of behavior and comfort.
poor acceleration on ice
increased fuel consumption at any speed
Suitable for any winter roads, but will reveal their best qualities on asphalt.

Points: 875
8
Hankook W419 i Pike RS
Excellent longitudinal traction on snow, high lateral traction on ice
Economical at any speed
Good ride comfort and directional stability on asphalt.
poor traction stability on snowy roads and handling, low passability
noisy
For any winter road; help save fuel.

Points: 873
9
Cordiant Snow Cross
Satisfactory handling and traction on snow and ice
Passing grades in handling and traction
poor braking on asphalt
difficult handling, noisy
Will help to feel confident on snow and ice.

Points: 861
from 3 550 
10
Bridgestone Blizzak Spike-01
Medium ice grip
precise on-course handling on asphalt
satisfactory on-road manners
Poor longitudinal grip on snow and braking properties on asphalt
increased fuel consumption
difficult handling
very noisy
They will show their best qualities on icy roads.

Score: 856
from 9 730 
11
Yokohama Ice Guard IG55
Good handling, directional stability on snowy roads and traction.
the weakest braking properties on snow and on dry asphalt, weak - on ice and on a wet road
difficult directional stability on asphalt
low level of comfort
For a leisurely ride on any winter roads.

Points: 855
from 5 060 
12
Avatyre Freeze (Нешип)
Average braking on asphalt
satisfactory ride smoothness
the weakest coupling properties on snow and ice
problematic handling and complex directional stability
low level of passability
Only for purified asphalt roads.

Points: 796
from 4 440