Summer tyre test 185/60 R15 от издательства Авторевю 2012 г.

You can read the full text of the test at the following link: https://autoreview.ru/articles/test
Place Model Description / Recommendations Cost
1
Michelin Energy Saver
Wet grip handling
Dry handling
Balanced performance across all test types
Excellent tires for Russian roads.

Score: 8.9/10
from 13 570 
2
Hankook K415 Optimo
Traction on wet asphalt
Handling on wet asphalt
High impact resistance
Increased noise level
Good tires, also not very expensive.

Score: 8.8/10
3
Pirelli Cinturato P1 Verde
Traction properties on wet asphalt
Brake properties on dry asphalt
Acoustic comfort
Ride smoothness
Insufficient sidewall strength when impacted
High rolling resistance
Very "Italian" tires: emotional, but not always balanced.

Score: 8.7/10
from 4 890 
4
Continental ContiEcoContact 5
Traction on wet asphalt
Braking and handling on dry asphalt
Comfort
Low rolling resistance
Insufficient sidewall strength on impacts
High price
Good tires for smooth roads, but for Russian "roads" - too delicate.

Points: 8.5/10
from 4 050 
5
Nokian Hakka Green
Dry road handling
Acoustic comfort
High impact resistance
Medium traction properties on wet asphalt
Not as "green" as Continental, but not as gentle either - a curb impact disabled the Nokian tires at a relatively high speed of 50 km/h. For Russia, such a combination of durability and economy is preferable.

Score: 8.3/10
6
Кама Евро 236
Aquaplaning resistance
High impact resistance
Dry asphalt handling
Insufficient ride smoothness
High rolling resistance
For driving on Russian roads - a worthy option.

Score: 8.3/10
7
Michelin Energy XM2
Excellent aquaplaning resistance
Smooth ride
Average traction properties on wet asphalt
Handling on wet asphalt
Maybe in the process of operation, other charms of new tires will manifest themselves (the manufacturer promises an increase in mileage by 20%), but with the presence of more "grippy" and, according to the results of our test, no less durable Michelin Energy Saver tires, it's better to buy Saver, not XM2.

Points: 8.2/10
8
Goodyear EfficientGrip
Smoothness of operation
Ease of handling on wet asphalt.
Insufficient impact resistance
Noisiness
Tires for smooth ride enthusiasts.

Rating: 7.9/10
from 16 100 
9
Federal Formoza FD1
High resistance to impact
Low cost
Low traction on wet asphalt
Handling on wet asphalt
High rolling resistance
By modern standards, the tires are mediocre, but in towns where there is no money for road repairs and never will be, they might be sufficient.

Score: 6.5/10
10
Bridgestone Ecopia EP100
Aoustic comfort
Low rolling resistance
Low aquaplaning resistance
Handling on wet and dry asphalt
Low grip properties on wet and dry asphalt
After the UHP class tire test, we had a suspicion that some "simplified" Bridgestone tires are being supplied to Russia, and now it has only intensified. But it will not be possible to compare them with those sold in Europe - instead of "Russian" tires of this model, Ecopia EP150 is sold there.

Scores: 6.1/10