Winter Tire Test 205/55 R16 from the publisher Tyre Reviews 2025 p.

Place Model Description / Recommendations Cost
1
Continental ContiVikingContact 8
Very good performance in any conditions
Good ride smoothness and low noise level
Very low rolling resistance
Relatively low resistance to lateral aquaplaning
Tires have an impressive balance of characteristics, combining a high level of safety in any conditions with comfort and economy, and it would be nice to improve only the resistance to aquaplaning in a turn
from 20 810 
2
Goodyear UltraGrip Ice 3
Good performance on dry pavement
Good handling on wet pavement
Very high resistance to aquaplaning
Excellent performance on snow and ice
Excellent ride smoothness
Low rolling resistance
Relatively long braking distance on a wet road
Except for not the highest efficiency on a wet surface, Goodyear has excellent driving qualities, which are combined with good ride comfort and a sufficiently low rolling resistance
from 21 170 
3
Nokian Hakkapeliitta R5
Excellent performance on dry and wet asphalt
High traction and good handling on snow
Good handling on rough ice
Excellent ride comfort
Low rolling resistance
On smooth ice, the traction leaves much to be desired
Weak resistance to lateral aquaplaning
Although Nokian tyres are usually made with an emphasis on snowy and icy road performance, the R5 had outstanding results on asphalt this time, but reduced grip on smooth ice, and a similar set of features is not very suitable for northern winter tyres.
from 4 800 
4
Michelin X-Ice Snow
Very short braking distance on snow
Excellent traction and braking performance on ice
Very weak performance on dry pavement
Long braking distance and overall weak grip on wet pavement
Increased rolling resistance
The Michelin X-Ice Snow is already showing signs of aging, and it particularly noticeably lags behind more modern models on asphalt, both dry and wet. At the same time, on snow and ice, Michelin still shows itself from the best side
from 9 720 
5
Marshal KW31
Acceptable performance on dry asphalt
Long braking distance and overall poor performance on wet surfaces
Negatively affect handling in any conditions
Very poor results on ice
High rolling resistance
Although the tires are designed for northern winter, the grip on snow and ice is clearly not the highest, i.e. Marshal is unlikely to be worthy of recommendation
from 4 620