Winter tire test 205/55 R16 from the publisher Авторевю 2010 p.

You can read the full text of the test at the following link: https://autoreview.ru/articles/test
Place Model Description / Recommendations Cost
1
Nokian Hakkapeliitta 7
Low Traction Wet Grip
Excellent Ice Braking and Handling on Ice and Snow
Loud
Average on dry asphalt
Points: 8.4
2
Continental ContiIceContact
Excellent traction and snow and ice handling capabilities.
Increased rolling resistance
Low traction properties on asphalt
Points: 8.3
from 10 450 
3
Michelin X-Ice North 2
Good snow and ice traction
Low rolling resistance
Improved fuel efficiency
Average handling characteristics
Average properties on dry and wet asphalt
Score: 8.0
4
Pirelli Winter Carving Edge
Improved traction
Excellent snow and ice handling
Noisy
Points: 8.0
5
Vredestein Arctrac
Excellent ice handling
Good performance on asphalt
Weak points on snow
Low acoustic comfort
Points: 8.3
6
Goodyear UltraGrip Extreme
Excellent on ice
Good on other surfaces
Rolling Resistance
Points: 7.9
7
Gislaved Nord Frost 5
Excellent performance on snow and ice.
Average performance on dry and wet asphalt
Low resistance to slashplaning
Score: 7.7
8
Yokohama Ice Guard IG35+
Good on asphalt
Average performance on snow and ice
Low resistance to slash planning
Points: 7.4
from 5 380 
9
Hankook RW09 Winter i Pike LT
Good traction on ice
Excellent value
Poor performance on snow
Low resistance to slash planning
Points: 7.0
from 6 710 
10
Sava Eskimo Ice (нешип)
Slip resistance
Poor traction on ice
Poor handling on any surface
Low acoustic comfort
Points: 7.0
from 1 780 
11
Cordiant Sno-Max
Traction Properties on Asphalt
Excellent Pricing
Handling and traction on ice and snow
Noise
Low resistance to slash-plaining
Points: 5.9
from 3 590 
12
Goodyear UltraGrip Ice+
Tread patterns for ice and snow in the non-treaded tire class
High anti-slipping resistance
Grip on wet and dry asphalt
Points: 7.4
from 3 700 
13
Continental ContiVikingContact 5
Traction on ice and snow in the non-studded tire class
High skid resistance
Traction on wet and dry asphalt
Braking performance and handling on wet asphalt
Points: 7.3
from 6 290 
14
Nokian Hakkapeliitta R
Improved snow and ice traction in studless tires
Low rolling resistance
High wear resistance to slushplaning
Traction on asphalt
Handling on asphalt
Scores: 7.3
15
Michelin X-Ice 2
Traction properties on ice in the non-studded tire class
Traction and handling on asphalt
Handling on ice
Points: 7.3
16
Yokohama Ice Guard IG30
High wet skid resistance
Braking properties on wet asphalt in non-treaded tyre class
Traction properties on ice
Handling on dry and wet asphalt
Score: 6.7
17
Dunlop Graspic DS3
High scrub resistance
Traction properties on snow
Handling on all types of coatings
Points: 6.3