Winter tire test of size 175/65 R14 from the publisher За рулём 2010 p.

Place Model Description / Recommendations Cost
1
Nokian Hakkapeliitta 7
Outstanding longitudinal traction on ice and cross-country traction on compacted snow
High traction
No surprises during cornering, braking and acceleration on winter roads
Low fuel consumption
Average braking performance on dry asphalt
Minor remarks regarding asphalt handling
Suitable for any winter roads. Will suit those who try to save fuel first and foremost.

Price/quality ratio: 3.82
Points: 927
2
Michelin X-Ice North 2
Excellent braking and acceleration on snow
Good cornering grip on ice
Outstanding directional stability on any surface and deep-snow traction
Good braking on dry asphalt
Low fuel consumption.
Modest braking properties on wet asphalt
Will give confidence on any winter roads. Will appeal to those for whom low fuel consumption is important.

Price/quality ratio: 3.58
Points: 927
3
Pirelli Winter Carving Edge
Good braking properties and snow acceleration
Lateral grip and dynamic performance on ice
Deep snow traction
Course stability on any winter roads
Intuitive handling
Moderate fuel consumption
The weakest braking performance on dry asphalt
Weak brakes on wet asphalt
Low level of comfort
Designed for any winter road. Economical enough.

Price/quality ratio: 2.84
Points: 884
4
Gislaved Nord Frost 5
Best ice-grip braking performance
Good acceleration on any surface and wet-road braking
Less-than-ideal handling and traction in deep snow
Increased noise level
Significant stud crunch
They will perform best on icy roads.

Value for money: 3.51
Points: 882
5
Кама 505
Good snow and dry asphalt braking
Satisfactory steering stability on any road surface
Modest cross-country traction on ice and snow
Braking on wet asphalt
Problematic handling on winter roads
Low level of comfort
Suitable for any winter roads.

Price/quality ratio: 2.45
Points: 837
from 3 510 
6
Cordiant Sno-Max
Superior braking performance on dry and wet asphalt
Satisfactory traction and directional stability on snowy roads.
Poor longitudinal traction on snow
Modest acceleration on ice
Unsatisfactory directional stability on asphalt
Increased fuel consumption
Low level of comfort
Suitable for any winter roads.

Price/quality ratio: 2.35
Points: 830
from 3 590 
7
Sava Eskimo Ice (нешип)
Good snow traction
Steering stability and handling on snowy roads
Quite comfortable
The weakest braking on ice, snow and wet asphalt

Lateral grip on snow
Difficult acceleration control on winter road
Suitable for partially snowy and slightly icy roads.

Price/quality ratio: 2.86
Points: 823
from 1 780 
8
Bridgestone Ice Cruiser 5000
Good traction on any surface and braking on dry asphalt
Satisfactory snow traction in deep snow.
Modest traction on ice and snow
Braking on wet asphalt
High fuel consumption
Difficult handling on winter roads
High noise level
Suitable for partially snow-covered and slightly icy roads.

Price/quality ratio: 2.89
Points: 819