Winter tire test 225/45 R17 from the publisher Autoexpress 2017 p.

Place Model Description / Recommendations Cost
1
Continental ContiWinterContact TS 860
Best handling on dry and wet road
shortest stopping distance on wet asphalt
safe braking on dry asphalt
low noise level.
slow enough on snow
requires carefulness when cornering on flooded asphalt
The ideal option for the city or for a mild winter.
from 6 090 
2
Hankook W452 Winter i cept RS2
Best snow handling performance
strongest traction and shortest stopping distance on snow
confident and precise handling on dry and wet roads
reduced rolling resistance
safe braking on wet asphalt.
tendency to skid when turning on wet asphalt
a sufficiently high level of noise
A lucky option for those who spend winter in the city - it will cope with any conditions.
from 3 660 
3
Dunlop SP Winter Sport 5
Best snow traction
decent dry handling and braking
safe wet stopping distance
low rolling resistance.
some tendency to understeer in aquaplaning tests
tendency to oversteer of the rear wheels on dry asphalt
The tire is not badly balanced, but it requires the driver's delicacy.
4
Goodyear Ultragrip Performance GEN-1
Precise steering response on snow
High aquaplaning resistance on straight runs
Lowest noise level
dangerously long braking distance on wet asphalt
requires control when moving on a wet road
A decent and not overly balanced tire for a careful driver.
from 6 760 
5
Nokian WR D4
Shorter braking distance on snow, strong snow traction, high cornering speed on winter roads, low rolling resistance, good dry handling.
long braking distance on wet asphalt (4 meters more than Conti)
insufficient resistance to aquaplaning when cornering
On snow - the queen of the track, on wet asphalt everything is not so rosy.
from 7 390 
6
Pirelli Winter Sottozero III
Best dry braking result
high lap time on wet
good handling and braking on wet roads.
The worst result in snow braking tests
reduced aquaplaning resistance on straight and in corner
high noise level
It's hard to call the tire an acceptable option for winter.
from 5 780 
7
Michelin Alpin A5
High aquaplaning resistance on straight line movement
slowed passage of turns
weak grip on dry asphalt and on snow
A vague option. Michelin can definitely do better!
from 8 620 
8
Bridgestone Blizzak LM001
Best wet grip performance
poor handling on snow and wet roads
worst test result for braking on dry road
high rolling resistance
long braking distance on snow and wet asphalt
Although the model was released in 2014, it is hopelessly outdated, and the tests clearly show this
from 7 140