Winter tire test R14 from the publisher Авторевю 2008 p.

You can read the full text of the test at the following link: https://autoreview.ru/articles/test
Place Model Description / Recommendations Cost
1
Nokian Hakkapeliitta 5
Traction on ice and snow
Handling on slippery surfaces
Comfort
Braking performance on asphalt
Handling on asphalt
Points: 9,2/10
2
Cordiant Sno-Max
Traction on ice and snow
Handling on slippery road surfaces
Braking performance on asphalt
handling on asphalt
Score: 8.9/10
from 3 590 
3
Matador MP-51 Sibir 2
Traction on ice and snow
Handling on slippery road surfaces
Braking performance on asphalt
Handling on asphalt
Points: 8,6/10
4
Yokohama Guardex F700Z
Accelerated dynamics on ice and snow
Handling on slippery road surfaces
handling on asphalt
Points: 8,2/10
5
Fortio WN-01
Medium wet traction
Dry handling
Flat tire prevention
noise
insufficient traction properties on ice
Score: 8/10
6
Росава WQ-102
Traction on ice
traction on asphalt
Noise
traction properties on snow
handling on slippery surfaces
Score: 8/10
7
Amtel NordMaster CL
Braking performance on snow
steering stability on slippery roads and on asphalt.
Ride smoothness
Points: 8/10
8
Hankook W440 Icebear
Braking properties on asphalt.
Handling on slippery roads
insufficient ride smoothness
Score: 7.9/10
9
Amtel NordMaster 2
Traction and handling on slippery surfaces
Smoothness of operation
Braking performance on ice
braking performance on asphalt
Score: 7.9/10
10
Кама 516
Braking properties on asphalt
drivability on asphalt
Poor handling on slippery roads
insufficient traction on ice and snow
noise
Score: 7.5/10
11
Green Diamond Alpin
Braking properties on snow
Handling on asphalt
ice traction properties
ride smoothness
Score: 7.5/10
12
Matador MP-58 Silika M+S
Comfort
traction properties and handling on asphalt.
Traction properties on ice
handling on slippery surfaces
Score: 7.4/10
13
Yokohama Ice Guard IG20
Tire acceleration on snow
Tire acceleration on ice
Braking properties on ice
low reliability of handling on slippery surfaces
braking properties and handling on asphalt
Points: 7.3/10
14
Cordiant Polar
Medium level of traction and handling on slippery surfaces
medium level of traction and handling on pavement.
Traction properties on ice and snow
noise
Points: 7.2/10
15
Kumho I Zen XW KW17
Traction on asphalt
Braking on asphalt.
Traction properties on ice and snow
handling on slippery surfaces
Points: 6.7/10